Our Menu
Experience the convenience of online ordering at Just Like Magic Bakery. Browse our selection of cupcakes and cookies available for purchase directly from our website. For custom cakes, wedding treats, and personalized creations, fill out our order form to bring your sweetest visions to life. Let us make every moment a little sweeter with our delectable delights.
Just Like Magic Menu
Call for Pricing : (570) 872-0132
Slices
**Can be purchased as a whole as well
Cheesecake
$7.25
Cake
$6.75
Pie
$4.25
Cake Roll
$4.50
Cinnamon Rolls & Pecan Rolls & Bread
Breads: Thursday - Sunday Only
Cinnamon Roll
$5.25
Pecan Roll
$5.75
Specialty Roll
$6.25
Italian Bread
$8.00
Cookies & Macarons
Macaron Individual
$3.25
Cookies Individual (4 oz.)
$4.65
Cookies Individual (2 oz.)
$2.00
Macarons
$3.25
Brownies
Plain Brownies
$3.50
Cookie Brownies
$4.50
Mini-Brownies
$2.25
Cupcakes & Muffins
Individual
$3.85
Buy 11 get 1 FREE
$42.35
Jumbo Cupcake
$5.50
Vegan Individual
$4.00
Gluten Free Individal
$4.00
Gluten Free Mini-Banana Bread
$4.25
Muffins Individual
$4.25
Additional Desserts
Parfaits
Large $6.50
Small $4.75
Edible Cookie Dough
$3.75 (a scoop - free topping with each scoop)
Cake Pucks
$3.75
Chocolate Covered Pretzels
$2.50
Mini Chocolate Chip Banana Bread
$4.00
Mousse
$5.25
Cannolis
Small $2.25 Large $3.50
Beverages
Coffee/Tea/Hot Chocolate
Small $2.65 Large $2.85
Bottled Water
$1.50
Can of Soda
$1.50
Cupcake Flavors
Almond Joy
An ultimate chocolate cake with silky chocolate buttercream, adorned with coconut, caramel, and chocolate drizzles, and finished with a chocolate-covered almond. A tropical escape in every decadent bite.
Banana Split
A vanilla cake filled with banana pudding, banana buttercream, and topped with nuts, chocolate syrup, and a cherry. A delightful homage to the iconic sundae, packed into a cupcake.
Blissfuls
A soft vanilla cake topped with luxuriously creamy cookie butter buttercream. A sweet, spiced treat that offers a comforting embrace with every bite.
Brown Sugar Butterscotch
A sumptuous butterscotch cake topped with creamy vanilla buttercream. A perfect blend of warmth and sweetness, crafted to delight with every bite.
Brownie Explosion
An ultimate chocolate cake topped with chocolate buttercream and generous chunks of brownie, drizzled with chocolate. A decadent delight for brownie and chocolate lovers alike.
Butterfinger
A vanilla cake with Butterfinger pieces in the batter, crowned with vanilla buttercream and more Butterfinger crumbles. A crunchy, buttery, chocolatey treat that satisfies with a candy bar twist.
Chocolate Caramel Pretzel
An ultimate chocolate cake with rich chocolate buttercream, topped with crushed pretzel for a salty crunch and a lavish caramel drizzle. A symphony of textures and flavors, masterfully combined for an unforgettable treat.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
A vanilla cake with a heart of edible cookie dough, topped with vanilla icing and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips. A whimsical treat that brings your favorite flavors together in one bite.
Chocolate Mint
A decadent chocolate cake crowned with a cool chocolate-mint buttercream. A harmonious blend of rich cocoa and invigorating mint, designed to enchant your taste buds.
Chocolate Salted Caramel
A rich chocolate cake beneath caramel buttercream, accented with a touch of sea salt and a lavish caramel drizzle. A decadent delight where sweet meets salty in perfect harmony.
Chocolate Strawberry
A chocolate cake filled with luscious strawberry filling and topped with chocolate buttercream mixed with freeze-dried strawberries. A romantic fusion of chocolate and strawberry, destined to delight.
Fluffer Nutter
A light vanilla cake paired with a smooth peanut butter buttercream. A comforting blend of flavors that evokes nostalgic pleasure in every bite.
Funfetti
A vibrant cake batter cake with creamy vanilla buttercream, dipped in colorful nonpareils. A festive and fun treat that's bursting with joy and sprinkles in every bite.
Galaxy
A rich, ultimate chocolate cake paired with silky vanilla buttercream. A signature creation that promises a universe of flavor in every bite.
Heath
A rich chocolate cake topped with chocolate buttercream and crushed Heath bar. A crunchy, buttery treat that combines smooth chocolate with the unmistakable charm of toffee.
Hint O Mint
A tender vanilla cake topped with a mint-infused vanilla buttercream and crowned with Andes Candies. A minty delight that offers a cool burst of flavor, perfectly balanced with sweet and creamy notes.
Lemon Coconut
A zesty lemon cake with luscious coconut buttercream, dipped in shredded coconut. A refreshing, beachy treat that combines the tang of lemon with the sweetness of coconut.
Lemon Raspberry
A zesty lemon cake with a raspberry filling, vanilla buttercream, and a raspberry drizzle. A bright and tangy delight that pairs the boldness of lemon with the sweetness of raspberry.
Love that Nila
A creamy vanilla cake with smooth vanilla buttercream, drizzled with vanilla, sprinkled with festive sprinkles, and topped with a Nilla wafer. A celebration of vanilla in its most delightful form.
M & M
A vanilla cake bursting with mini M & M's, topped with vibrant vanilla buttercream and more mini M & M's. A cheerful, chocolatey treat that's as delightful to look at as it is to eat.
Malt Shoppe
A nostalgic chocolate cake with a creamy chocolate-Ovaltine buttercream. A classic treat that captures the sweet essence of a bygone era, perfect for malt lovers.
Nutter Butter
A light vanilla cake paired with a smooth peanut butter buttercream. A comforting blend of flavors that evokes nostalgic pleasure in every bite.
Oreo
A decadent chocolate cake with Oreo buttercream, garnished with half an Oreo and a chocolate drizzle. An irresistible treat that brings together everyone's favorite cookie in cupcake form.
Peanut Butter Explosion
A chocolate cake topped with creamy peanut butter buttercream and crowned with a Reese's cup. A bold combination of chocolate and peanut butter that's irresistibly indulgent.
Reese Pieces
A vanilla cake with Reese's in the batter, crowned with peanut butter buttercream and sprinkled with Reese's Pieces. A peanut butter lover's dream, delivering a crunch and creaminess in every bite.
Ruby Red
A classic red velvet cake adorned with luscious vanilla buttercream. An iconic treat that wraps rich cocoa flavors and velvety smoothness into a visually stunning dessert.
Razzle Dazzle
A chocolate cake with vibrant raspberry buttercream and a luscious drizzle of raspberry sauce. A dazzling combination that balances rich chocolate with the tart sweetness of raspberry.
SMORES
An ultimate chocolate cake with a gooey marshmallow filling, topped with chocolate buttercream, graham cracker crumbs, freeze-dried marshmallows, and a chocolate drizzle. A cozy, fireside treat in every bite.
Samoa
A moist chocolate cake topped with coconut buttercream, a luxurious chocolate and caramel drizzle, and sprinkled with coconut, finished with half a Samoa cookie. A bite-sized homage to the beloved cookie.
Salted Caramel
A vanilla cake topped with smooth caramel buttercream, finished with a sprinkle of sea salt and a generous caramel drizzle. A balanced fusion of flavors that tantalizes the taste buds.
The Stroud
A classic vanilla cake with fluffy vanilla buttercream and mini chocolate chips scattered throughout. A delightful blend of smooth vanilla and rich chocolate chips for a timeless taste.
The Winterfest
A bright lemon cake paired with lemon blackberry buttercream. A refreshing bite that combines the tang of lemon with the sweet, earthy notes of blackberry for a winter-inspired treat.
Ultimate Oreo
An ultimate chocolate cake with cream filling, topped with vanilla buttercream mixed with chunks of Oreo and a chocolate drizzle. A decadent exploration of textures and tastes, perfect for Oreo enthusiasts.
Vanilla Raspberry
A tender vanilla cake with a sweet raspberry filling